Skip to content

Smart Marketing Show is no longer in production

Play Video

On this episode, Jason and Bridget talk with Amy Hall on how to build up your mailing list and how to keep your email marketing audience interested.

The WPwatercooler network is sponsored by ServerPress makers of DesktopServer. Be sure to check them out at as well as VendorFuel at

If you’re interested in sponsoring the 40-minute mark of this show, check out the details on our sponsor page. We offer episode by episode spoken ads, rather than large contracts. A show by you for you.

“To anybody watching, stop emailing people that don’t want an email from you just so you can say your list is big.” Bridget

“Website for show; email for dough.” AmyHall.Biz

What am I selling?

Everything is a sale. No matter what, it’s a sale. You’re selling attention and time.

“Even if you’re not exchanging money, you want their time.” Amy Hall

They might not click the button on the email, but it is the system that will feed the purchase, says Amy. They are the moneymaker. They’ll see you on social and then go look for the email. Then they will purchase.

How do you get people to subscribe?

It really has nothing to do with the email provider you choose. It matters more about your website and the emails you’re sending.

How do you know if you’re emailing too much?

You email too often when you get a bunch of unsubscribes. Everyone’s tolerance is different.

How do you get people to attend a show?

As much as you can, make the topic known.

WPwatercooler is an event. By the time Amy gets the email, for example, she’s already planned Thursdays. Send out the event email two weeks before, three days before, and the day before.

Bridget suggests using Mailchimp’s tagging feature in an audience in order to recruit guests from 2019, 2018, etc.

Highlight some of the previous guests and how their business has progressed since they started being on the show, says Amy.

“You are the average of the five people you spend the most time with.” – Jim Rohn

How do you get people to subscribe to your list?

Anyone who has been on WPwatercooler is manually added to the list. Posting to Facebook isn’t a good way to get subscribers, says Amy Hall.

What about open rates?

Ensure that your headline is engaging and short (30-40 characters).

“You need clear, concise, short subject lines.” Amy Hall

Headlines can be sensational or the same every week “Real Estate News from John Doe.” They saw it in their email every week and they came to expect it.

“There is no formula for it. You have to test it.” Amy Hall

Asking for help is always a good way to get people to open. Also, don’t count on people reading the preview text in their email browser of choice. Repeat that copy and the subject line in the body of the email.

How to you keep people engaged with email marketing?

What is the benefit of being on the show?

Personalize, personalize, personalize. Amy says you should sprinkle their first name throughout the body of the email.

Ensure that you offer the value propositions (reasons) why someone would want to be on the show. Talk about stats, exclusivity, and the like.

Tool or Tip of the Week

This Tool or Tip of the week is brought to you by VendorFuel. VendorFuel is a next-generation shopping cart plugin that will ignite your eCommerce. Built using AngularJS VendorFuel lets you keep your customers on your website for the entire checkout experience. Start a 90-day free trial now and Ignite Your eCommerce at!

Bridget loves Beaver Builder so much. She sent a pre-sales client her affiliate link this week. They loved that

Amy loves as an email client. Worth every dollar.

Jason recommends Coursera for certifications.

Do you have any tools or tips we should know about?

We’d love to hear from you. What are your experiences with this subject?

Tell us in the comments below.

Become a Patron and support us on Patreon!

Become a Patron!

Episode Info

Podchaser - Smart Marketing Show
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

WPblab EP133 – Keeping Your Email Marketing Audiences Interested

@Jason Tucker and @youtoocanbeguru talk with @GenuineAmyHall on how to build up your mailing list and how to keep your email marketing audience interested.…
#wordpress #email #marketing

Gaurav Vohra

thanks for the shoutout @GenuineAmyHall 🙂

“Amy loves as an email client. Worth every dollar.”…

David Bell

This Article was mentioned on

Nicholas Pardon

This Article was mentioned on

Amy Hall

This Article was mentioned on


This Article was mentioned on

Mark A Hope

This Article was mentioned on

“You need clear, concise, short subject lines.” @GenuineAmyHall


Bridget Willard

This Article was mentioned on

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
Scroll To Top